Hey it’s Chase and Jimmy here! 

Owala turned a product launch into a party—and brought their email flow along for the ride.

From the moment of opt-in to the second their Birthday Bash bottle was on the way, the experience was bold, playful, and packed with personality.

But even the best birthday celebrations have room to improve.

This week’s breakdown looks at what Owala nailed, where the flow missed, and what eCommerce brands can learn from a launch that wasn’t just a drop—it was an event.

Plus, keep reading for an AI prompt that will fast track your A/B subject line testing and an AI tool that's reshaping the retention marketing world for the better.

Let’s dive in 👇

🙃 Meme Drop

Credit: The Marketing Millennials

🤨 AI isn't the enemy. But it is on thin ice.

Consumers like AI in eCommerce… until it starts making decisions for them.

📊 In a new report from Omnisend, 66% of shoppers said they refuse to let AI complete purchases on their behalf—even if it means better deals.

They want help, not control.

Suggestions, not spam.

Personalization, not pressure.

Read the full breakdown on what shoppers really think about AI—so you can build trust, boost conversions, and avoid creeping people out.

🎉 A Breakdown of Owala’s Birthday Bash Email Flow: Wins, Misses & Opportunities for Even More Fun

Owala’s brand voice is playful, self-aware, and designed to stand out in a sea of boring hydration products—and their Birthday Bash email flow leans into that energy hard. From a clear opt-in to product launch hype to quirky post-purchase messaging, the whole journey feels like an actual party.

But even great party hosts miss a detail or two. Let’s take a look at what worked, what caused a little confusion, and how this already strong launch journey could become even more impactful.

1. The Opt-In: Hype With Heart

Owala’s entry point was an ad for their Birthday Bash collection. Clicking through led to an email sign-up to “join the fun.” The first email welcomed you with personality-packed copy and introduced their hero product (FreeSip) in the same breath.

✅ Wins

• Great copywriting that matches their tone: “The coolest products for the coolest people (which now includes you).”

• Visual-forward design with a lifestyle focus that makes the brand feel social and fun

• Smart product plug at the bottom—early nudge toward conversion with a “Shop FreeSip” CTA
  

🚀 Upgrade Ideas

• Consider a reminder of the exact reason you signed up (“You’re in for the Birthday Bash!”) for better continuity with the ad experience

• Add a calendar invite or countdown to build momentum toward launch

2. What to Expect: Launch Details Done Right

Next came a detailed pre-launch email laying out exactly how the drop would work: the date, time, how backorders would function, and what to expect if products sold out.

✅ Wins

• Super clear info—Owala avoided any surprises about restocks, ship times, or backorder details

• Maintains a fun tone while delivering logistics (not easy to do)

• Polaroid-style visuals keep the email engaging and thematic
  

🚀 Upgrade Ideas

• Add a “Get Notified” or SMS opt-in here for one more reminder at drop time

• Highlight the product themes a little more upfront—give subscribers something to look forward to

• A brief “which bottle vibe are you?” quiz could’ve added playful pre-engagement

3. Launch Day: The Collection Goes Live

On launch day, Owala sent out a vibrant, scroll-worthy email featuring all the themed bottles from “Girls Night In” to “Black Tie Affair.”

✅ Wins

• Creative, clear layout that reads like an event lineup

• Encourages browsing by theme, not just price or color—smart for AOV and engagement

• Multiple “Shop Now” CTAs invite immediate action
  

🚀 Upgrade Ideas

• Consider adding “Almost Gone” or real-time social proof badges on popular styles or include a mini “Top Picks” section for overwhelmed shoppers

• A short GIF or animation might’ve added even more party energy

  
  

  

4. Order Confirmation: Clean and Functional

After purchasing a Birthday Bash bottle, the order confirmation email was simple and straightforward. It didn’t lean as heavily into brand tone, but it got the job done.

✅ Wins

• Clear, digestible order summary

• Easy access to order details via a “View your order” CTA

• Consistent branding through visuals, even if copy was minimal
  

🚀 Upgrade Ideas

• Surface next steps more clearly (e.g. estimated ship window, tracking expectations)

• Add a “How to care for your bottle” link or teaser for what’s coming next (UGC, social tags, etc.)

• Could include a referral code or prompt to share your Birthday Bash pick on social
  
  

  

5. The 20% Off Email: Wait… Did I Miss a Deal?

Shortly after the purchase, an email dropped with the subject line “20% Off Ends Soon.” Turns out, the fine print excluded Birthday Bash bottles—but that wasn’t clear at a glance.

✅ Wins

• Keeps the party theme alive with scrapbook-style imagery

• Good urgency play for customers who hadn’t yet purchased
  

🚀 Upgrade Ideas

• This email shouldn’t have gone to recent Birthday Bash buyers—tighten segmentation to avoid regret or confusion

• Make exclusions clearer in the hero copy, not just in the fine print

  
  

  

🎯 What’s Working Well

✅ Consistent visual branding across the flow—bright, bold, and unmistakably Owala
✅ Pre-launch communication was clear and proactive (a rarity!)
✅ Smart use of themed collections to create narrative and product discoverability
✅ Transactional emails maintained polish and functionality, even if less personality-packed

❌ Opportunities to Improve

• Segmentation slip-up: Birthday Bash buyers shouldn’t have received the 20% off email unless it was framed as a “shop more” moment with clarified exclusions

• Missing next steps post-purchase: Consider following up with fun content like user photos, behind-the-scenes, product care or “how it’s made” stories

• No post-launch drip: Once the launch happened, there was a bit of a drop-off—there’s room for a longer journey to keep new customers engaged

Final Verdict: A Launch With Personality—and Room to Party Even Harder 🎈

Owala nailed the brand voice and visual consistency across the Birthday Bash email flow. The messaging was clear, fun, and creative—making customers feel like part of something bigger than just a bottle purchase.

With a few segmentation tweaks and more post-purchase storytelling, this customer journey could go from great to truly unforgettable.

Final Verdict

Overall, Buffy’s email flow is strong but has room for fine-tuning. The brand excels at creating excitement and providing clear next steps for customers, but with a few adjustments, it can further improve the customer experience. By focusing on personalization, clarity, and urgency, Buffy can enhance its email strategy and drive even more conversions.

🛠️ Turn Your Retention Strategy Into an Always-On Machine

Retention marketing has always been a team sport. Now you can add AI to the roster.

With Raleon, DTC brands are building AI-powered teams that:

✅ Understand customer behavior

✅ Launch personalized campaigns

✅ Optimize performance in real-time

This isn’t theoretical—it’s already helping top brands drive higher LTV, reduce churn, and do more with less.

Build your AI Agent team like you would a real one—share goals, context, and tools—and let Raleon do the heavy lifting across email, onsite, and beyond.

👉 Ready to see it in action? Book a demo with Raleon.

🤖 AI Power Up: A/B Test Subject Lines in Seconds

📧 Struggling to pick the right subject line?

Instead of guessing, let AI help you test before you send.

👉 Prompt:

"Write 10 subject lines for an email about [insert topic or product]. Include a mix of curiosity, urgency, and clarity. Then analyze and rank them by potential open rate, explaining why each ranks where it does."

This gives you a fast shortlist of options and insights into what might catch attention.

✅ Bonus: Once you pick 2-3 favorites, plug them into a subject line tester (like Omnisend’s free tool) for a quick second opinion before A/B testing live.

Annnnd that’s a wrap for this edition! 

Thanks for hanging with Chase and me—always a pleasure to have you here.

If you found this newsletter helpful (or even just a little fun), don’t keep it to yourself! Share ecomemailmarketer.com with your favorite DTC marketer. Let’s get them on board so they don’t miss next week’s drops.

Remember: Do shit you love.

🤘 Jimmy Kim & Chase Dimond

Love this newsletter but want to receive it less frequently? Let us know by clicking here!