In My Jammers pays repeat buyers with their own points: the 12 messages they get in 3 daysIn My Jammers, a family-owned bamboo pajama brand, sent one returning customer six emails and six texts across two orders in three days. Some of it is the best repeat-buyer messaging we’ve seen this year. Some of it trips over itself, because the post-purchase, cart, loyalty and SMS flows are all reaching the same person at once. Here’s the flow stage by stage, with what to steal and what to fix before Black Friday. 1. Post-purchase: a confirmation that remembers them
The order confirmation opens with “You came back...and as a small, family-owned brand, that means everything to us,” and says the new set “is going to be just as loved as your last one.” A text follows with the points the order earned. 
Steal: a separate confirmation for repeat buyers. It’s one split on order count. Fix: there are no order details, just a button. Even a repeat buyer wants to see what they ordered. 2. Abandoned cart: pay them with points they already have
The subject line is “Wait, you have a discount on your order!” Under the cart item sits the shopper’s loyalty balance and a button that turns 2,000 points into $10 off. Steal: the points balance as the cart incentive. The shopper already earned the reward, so you’re not inventing a new discount. It worked here, too: the shopper redeemed and ordered the same afternoon. Fix: the subject line promises a discount the shopper has to unlock with points. “Your points can take $10 off” is just as strong and doesn’t feel like a bait and switch. 3. Loyalty: a fast reward and a slow welcome
Joining the rewards program sends a welcome text, and two minutes later an email with the $10 code. Steal: the speed. The reward lands while the shopper is still on the site. Fix: give the code an expiry date so it’s a reason to come back if they don’t buy right away. And send the welcome email with the welcome text. Here it showed up a full day later, after the shopper had already redeemed and ordered. 
4. The second order gets a generic confirmation
The Monday order got Shopify’s default confirmation instead of the branded one from the day before. Same customer, one day apart, and this one reads like a receipt. Fix: find out why the custom confirmation didn’t send, and brand the default template too, so a missed trigger still looks like you. 5. The founder note: the email to copy first
Half an hour after the third order, a plain-text email arrives from “Sara @ In My Jammers”: “Three orders in and I just have to say, you are kind of our favorite type of person.” Steal: all of it. It’s triggered by order count, it comes from a real name, and it has no design at all. Fix: it asks the shopper to set up a rewards account they made 30 minutes earlier. A check on whether the account exists would let that paragraph say something more useful. 6. Where the flows trip over each other
A low-stock text for a different product arrived half an hour before the cart email, so two messages competed for the same click. The shipping text came twice. And the points balance in the welcome email doesn’t match what the cart email showed, minus the points that were spent. 
None of these is a big mistake on its own. Together, they’re what happens when each flow is built by itself and none of them checks what the others already sent. Steal this before the 27th✓ Split your order confirmation on order count ✓ Put the loyalty balance in your cart email ✓ Send a plain-text note from a real person on the third order ✓ Make sure every order gets your branded confirmation ✓ Check for a rewards account before asking someone to make one ✓ Send your SMS and email welcomes at the same time
Before Black Friday, set aside an hour to walk through your flows the way a repeat buyer would. That’s the week all of them fire at once. |
Reply