Hey, it's Chase and Jimmy here.

Kitsch didn’t just adjust their cart recovery emails for Q4. They rebuilt the entire journey to feel festive, friendly, and personal. From holiday-themed visuals to interactive surveys, the flow blends conversion with customer understanding in a way that feels natural, not pushy. This morning we're breaking down the full sequence to see how the experience works together.

Also inside:
✔️ The cart that got away... (until now)
✔️ Steal the emails that actually work
✔️ AI Power-Up: Q5 Conversions

Let’s jump in👇.

The cart that got away... (until now)

Most shoppers don’t abandon carts on purpose; they get distracted, overwhelmed, or hit with surprise costs. The good news is these are all solvable problems (especially with Omnisend’s new guide).

They break down 40+ high-converting SMS templates, the psychology behind what actually gets people to return, and the optimization tactics top brands use to recover more revenue with less effort. Get the goods here.

Kitsch’s Holiday-Ready Abandoned Cart Flow

1. Welcome To Kitsch!

Focus: Greeting new subscribers and driving first purchase

What worked well
✔ Festive design immediately signals a seasonal moment and creates urgency
✔ Strong intro incentive of 30 percent off drives early conversions
✔ Clear CTA hierarchy keeps the focus on exploring best sellers

Opportunities for improvement
❌ The welcome popup framing sits low on mobile. Shifting the CTA higher could improve clicks
❌ Could highlight top categories with one sentence of value to help new shoppers navigate faster

2. Your Cart Is Looking For Some Love...💕

Focus: Recovering the abandoned cart with reassurance and product visibility

What worked well
✔ Soft, personable language makes the nudge feel friendly rather than pushy
✔ Product image, reviews, and discount paired together create a strong credibility signal
✔ Smart use of a small “You may also love” section to add complementary items

Opportunities for improvement
❌ The hero sale bar blends into the background. Increasing visual contrast could strengthen  urgency
❌ Four of the recommended products are nearly identical brushes. Replacing repeats with true complements like clips, towels, or accessories would make the recommendations feel intentional and tied to the original cart item.

3. Still thinking it over? Your pick is 30 percent Off! 🤗

Focus: Re-engaging hesitant shoppers with a strong offer

What worked well
✔ Effective social proof with customer reviews centered directly under the hero product
✔ Clear messaging around the 30 percent discount makes the value unmistakable
✔ “You May Also Love” acts as a subtle cross-sell moment while staying cart-focused

Opportunities for improvement
❌ The testimonial text is small. Increasing size could boost impact
❌ CTA could benefit from a secondary reminder about the discount expiration window

4. What’s Your Hair Type?

Focus: Educational assistance to guide product selection

What worked well
✔ Smart pivot into education. Shoppers who hesitate often need clarity, not more discounts
✔ Visual product tiles organized by hair type help remove decision friction
✔ Strong design consistency with the rest of the flow while still giving this email a purpose

Opportunities for improvement
❌ Instead of a full quiz, each button could be tagged to track interest and feed lightweight contextual data straight into segments for future personalization.
❌ Could include a small “based on what customers with your cart item choose” block to bridge the gap between education and conversion.

5. We want to know what you like! 👉

Focus: Collecting zero-party data to personalize future emails

What worked well
✔ This is the hero of the flow. The survey drives personalization and long-term retention
✔ Stunning visual layout makes the survey feel fun to complete
✔ Asks for both product preferences and content preferences which improves future segmentation

Opportunities for improvement
❌ A progress indicator or “takes 15 seconds” note could ease friction and increase survey completion rates.
❌ Adding a small incentive such as early access, bonus points, or a one-time discount could give hesitant shoppers a reason to finish the survey.

6. You Left Me Hanging...

Focus: Final push to recover the cart before shoppers move on

What worked well
✔ Great subject line tone. Lighthearted without sounding gimmicky
✔ Reintroduces the cart item and 30 percent offer in a clean, simple layout
✔ “You May Also Love” provides last-chance add-ons to increase AOV before checkout

Opportunities for improvement
❌ Could add a small scarcity cue like “Selling fast today”
❌ Footer icons crowd the end of the email. Spacing adjustments could make the close cleaner

What Kitsch Gets Right

• Seasonal design refresh that instantly makes the flow feel timely and relevant for the holidays

• Smooth transition from cart recovery to education, reducing friction instead of pushing discounts too hard

• Strong use of social proof with reviews placed directly under cart items

• Interactive elements like surveys that feed future personalization

• Clear visual structure that keeps the experience on-brand and easy to navigate

• Value-forward messaging that speaks to self-care, not just price

Where They Miss the Mark

• Repeated product recommendations limit discovery and weaken the intent signal

• Some CTAs and headline bars blend into the design and lose urgency

• Data capture moments could be even stronger with micro-interactions or intent tags

• Long product grids feel heavy on mobile and could be simplified

• The flow could use one strong “last chance” or “selling fast” cue to drive final conversions

Final Takeaway

Kitsch turned a standard abandoned cart journey into a festive, relationship-building experience that trades pushiness for personalization. The holiday touches, education-focused middle emails, and interactive survey give shoppers room to explore while still guiding them toward checkout. With a few tweaks to product variety and data capture strategy, this flow could become a top-tier retention asset for Q4 and beyond.

Key Takeaways for Brands

✔️ Seasonal design updates can make even evergreen flows feel timely
✔️ Move beyond discount reminders by adding education that resolves hesitation
✔️ Refresh product recommendations so they feel personalized, not repeated
✔️ Use micro-interactions to gather useful behavioral data without adding friction
✔️ Cross-sells should complement the cart, not distract from it
✔️ A balance of soft nudges and clear urgency wins more carts back

Steal the emails that actually work

Tired of staring at a blank screen wondering what to send next? The Inbox Index is your shortcut to smarter campaigns. We pulled real emails from top ecommerce brands and broke down exactly why they work so you can replicate the strategy, not the guesswork.

What’s inside:
- Real campaign examples from winning brands
- Takeaway breakdowns and frameworks
- Inspiration for flows, promos, launches, and retention
- Actionable insights you can plug into your next send

Download your free copy.

AI Power-Up: Q5 Conversions

Q5 (December 26 to January 15) is the most underrated growth window in ecommerce.

Shoppers have gift cards, new routines, fresh motivation, and inbox space again.

While competitors are “recovering from BFCM,” you can capture the cleanest pipeline of intent all year.

Use AI to predict and target high-intent Q5 buyers

Feed your data into AI to identify which customers are most likely to purchase again within 30–45 days. Then deploy predictive segments like:

• Likely to reorder within 7 / 14 / 30 days

• High AOV customers from gifting season

• Subscribers at risk of churn

• Loyal returning customers with high LTV

• Cart abandoners after Christmas week

Then have AI generate tailored campaigns

• Resolution / transformation themes aligned with product category

• Gift card redemption flow

• Personalized recommendations based on December behavior

• UGC + reviews campaign for social proof

• Q5 flash offers for second-order buyers

AI Prompt You Can Use Today

Analyze buyer behavior from December and identify segments most likely to purchase again in January.

Generate a 5-email Q5 campaign sequence personalized by segment, focusing on second purchase, gift card redemption, and product recommendations tied to New Year goals.

Include a retention-focused CTA and a VIP early access angle.

Annnnd that’s a wrap for this edition! 

Thanks for hanging with Chase and me. Always a pleasure to have you here.

If you found this newsletter helpful (or even just a little fun), don’t keep it to yourself! Share ecomemailmarketer.com with your favorite DTC marketer. Let’s get them on board so they don’t miss next week’s drops.

Remember: Do shit you love.

🤘 Jimmy Kim & Chase Dimond

PS - Your next best customer might be reading this right now. Want in? Email Jimmy to sponsor this newsletter and more.

Love this newsletter but want to receive it less frequently? Let us know by clicking here!