Hey it’s Chase and Jimmy here!

March is stacked: International Women's Day, St. Patrick's Day, Pi Day, Easter, all within a few weeks.

This email from Milk Bar treated the entire month as one extended gifting occasion and positioned their desserts as the solution for every celebration coming up.

It's a clean way to stay relevant without over-emailing, but the execution leaves some conversions on the table. Today we're breaking down what works and where better product visibility could actually drive sales.

Also inside:
✔️ Your email list is probably worth 10x what you think it is
✔️ Plot twist: The best email designs aren't actually that creative.
✔️ Hiring vault: 9 New retention marketing job ops

Let’s get into it.

Everything we know about retention. Finally in one place.

50 proven campaigns. 75+ real brand emails. 130+ pages of welcome flows. 10 copywriting frameworks. Design secrets from 10,000+ high-performing campaigns. A private community of 350+ retention marketers. Lifetime access to all of it.

That’s the eCom Retention Vault.

We spent 15+ years and watched $200M+ flow through email and SMS to figure out what actually works. Then we packaged every pattern, every playbook, and every framework into one place.

Not a subscription. Not a trial. One payment and it’s yours forever.

If a single campaign idea improves one flow, it pays for itself ten times over. There are 50 campaign ideas in here.

👉 Unlock the eCom Retention Vault

Milk Bar's March email: Turning a packed calendar into multiple reasons to buy

Milk Bar sells baked goods and desserts, and this email treats the entire month of March like one extended gifting occasion.

It's a smart way to stay relevant without sending four separate emails, and it positions their products as the answer for every celebration on the calendar.

Let's break down what's working and where there's room to improve.

Header Block

Right at the top, Milk Bar sets the premise: March is packed with reasons to celebrate, and they've got you covered.

What We Love

• The hero image shows abundance. The tower of treats, packaging, and products creates an immediate "wow" factor that makes everything feel premium.

• "A month of Milk Bar" is a strong framing device. It positions the brand as your go-to for the entire month, not just one event.

• The intro copy lists out the occasions. "From International Women's Day, to the start of daylight savings, St. Patrick's Day to Pi Day and Easter - the March calendar is full of reasons to party, and we've got just the treats for the job." It's clear, comprehensive, and creates urgency without being pushy.

• The free shipping callout at the very top removes a common objection immediately.

What We'd Do Differently

• There's no CTA above the fold. After that big hero image and the "game plan" setup, adding a "Shop All Treats" button would give eager shoppers a fast path to browse.

• The intro could be tighter. The daylight savings mention feels like filler; it's not really a gifting moment like the other holidays listed.

• The layout could use more white space. The hero image, headline, and body copy all run together, which makes it harder to scan.

Body Block

Here's where they walk you through specific product recommendations for different occasions.

What We Love

• Each section ties a product to a specific moment. "Show up with pie" for Easter and Pi Day, "Send truffles" for celebrating women, "Something for me" for self-care; intent is clear.

• The product recommendations are specific. Milk Bar Pie, B'Day Cake Truffles, Chocolate Covered Strawberry Caramel Snaps; you know exactly what you're getting.

• Each section gets its own CTA. "ORDER NOW" is consistent, clear, and easy to spot.

• The imagery supports the vibe. Lifestyle shots (pie on a plate, truffles on a stand, someone holding a treat) make the products feel accessible and real.

What We'd Do Differently

• There's no pricing. Showing the price next to each product would help people make faster decisions and reduce surprise at checkout.

• The "Something for me" section feels tacked on. It's not tied to a holiday or occasion like the others, which makes it feel like an afterthought. Either commit to self-care as a real angle or cut it.

• No social proof. Customer reviews, ratings, or a "fan favorite" badge would add credibility and help hesitant shoppers convert.

• The sections lack visual hierarchy. Every recommendation gets the same treatment, so there's no guidance on what's most popular or what to try first.

Footer Block

Milk Bar wraps up with clean navigation and standard contact info.

What We Love

• Navigation is simple and functional. Shop Online, Recipes, Locations, Loyalty; everything you'd need is right there.

• The contact link is clear. "If you have any questions, please contact us" makes support feel accessible.

• Social links are easy to spot and cover the right platforms.

What We'd Do Differently

• There's no final CTA or summary. After walking through all those product options, there's no "Browse the full collection" or "Shop all March treats" to capture late scrollers.

• The footer could reinforce trust. Adding "Free shipping over $100" or "Easy returns" would help hesitant buyers take the next step.

• The "Manage your subscription" link feels random without context. If subscriptions are important to the business, call them out earlier in the email.

Where This Email Works

Let's zoom out and see where this fits in the bigger email strategy.

Multi-Holiday Campaigns: This is a smart play when the calendar is packed and you don't want to send separate emails for every occasion. One email, multiple entry points.

Engaged Subscribers: Great for people who already know Milk Bar and just need a reminder of what to order for upcoming events.

Gifting Windows: Perfect for shoppers who are planning ahead and want to knock out multiple occasions at once.

Final Thoughts: Smart calendar play, needs better product visibility

This email does a good job of leveraging the calendar to create multiple reasons to buy. The product recommendations are clear, the occasions make sense, and the visuals are strong.

But it's leaving conversions on the table. The product links are hard to spot, there's no pricing, and the "Something for me" section feels disconnected from the rest of the email. Adding better visual hierarchy, making product links more obvious, and tightening up the self-care angle would help convert more browsers without losing the multi-occasion framing.

3 Quick Wins to Steal Next Time

✓ Use a packed calendar month to create multiple purchase triggers in one email
✓ Tie each product recommendation to a specific occasion so it feels relevant
✓ Make product links visually distinct so people don't have to hunt for them

Plot twist: The best email designs aren't actually that creative.

Most email templates look similar for a reason (and it's not laziness). Join Omnisend's visual expert Milvydas on March 24 at 7:00 AM PT to learn the design framework behind emails that actually perform, not just look good.

What you'll learn:

• Why high-performing email templates follow the same structural patterns

• The key design principles that drive conversions (not just aesthetics)

• The proven formula for creating emails that balance beauty with performance

This isn't about following trends; it's about understanding the design choices that consistently work across industries and audiences. → Register free

The Hiring Vault

• Director of Lifecycle Marketing (Email & SMS), Scottsdale, AZ: Sleepyhead

• Lifecycle Marketing Specialist (US - REMOTE), Oceanside, CA: Kindred Bravely

• Lifecycle Marketing Manager, Los Angeles, CA: Heat Free Hair

• Lifecycle Marketing Manager, Los Angeles, CA: Reformation

• Retention Specialist II, Carlsbad, CA: Vuori

• Sr. Manager, Retention Marketing, rhode, Beverly Hills, CA: E.L.F. BEAUTY

• Director, Lifecycle Marketing, Los Angeles, CA: True Classic

• Email & Lifecycle Marketing Manager, Austin, TX: Texas Standard

• Director Email Marketing - Hybrid from NY or WI, New York, NY:
  Lands'​ End

That's a wrap for today!

Appreciate you hanging with Chase and me. We hope you found something you can put to work ASAP.

If you did, don’t keep it to yourself! Send ecomemailmarketer.com to your favorite DTC marketer and get them in on the action.

Catch you next time!

🤘 Jimmy Kim

PS - Your next best customer might be reading this right now. Want in? Email Jimmy to sponsor this newsletter and more.

Love this newsletter but want to receive it less frequently? Let us know by clicking here!