🎙️ Tomorrow, November 17th at 9am PST / 12pm EST, we’re going live with the Omnisend team to fix your Black Friday plan before it ships. It’s free, so bring your half-built flows. Save your seat → |  | Mon 11/16 · Ed 459 | Every gift shopper is asking the same question: will they actually like this?Plenty of holiday emails skip right past it. They show the products, the discount and the deadline, then leave the shopper to work out who each thing is for (we’ve all stood in a store doing that math). Athletic Brewing’s gift email answers it in five words: “For the NA-curious or first-timers.” The shopper knows who the bundle is for before they’ve read anything else. This morning, we’re breaking down why that one line works, where the email could convert even harder, and what you can steal for your own gift sends. 👇 Also inside → The five-word line that does the gift matching for your shopper → Why the footer’s two loudest buttons have nothing to do with this order → A live hour with us tomorrow → The customers you haven’t heard from since last Christmas → Nine retention roles that went live this week
| Live webinar Bring your Black Friday plan to us tomorrow
Tomorrow, November 17th at 9am PST / 12pm EST, we’re going live with the Omnisend team for an hour of fixing Black Friday plans. It’s free, and it’s ten days before Black Friday, which is about the last spare hour you’ll get this month. Here’s what you’ll leave with: ✓ The three-way list split that keeps your best customers at the front of the line ✓ A five-minute check for your cart and browse flows ✓ The send schedule we’d run Black Friday week if it were our store ✓ The one number to check an hour after your first send, before your boss asks
Bring your questions and your half-built flows. We’ll get through as many as we can, live. Save your seat → | Segment of the week Last year’s holiday gift buyersHere’s a group most of us forget about until it’s too late: people whose first order came in between November 15th and December 24th last year, and who haven’t ordered since. Plenty of them never came back because they weren’t shopping for themselves. They were buying for someone else, and they’re about to do it again. How to build it: first order placed between November 15th and December 24th, 2025, and zero orders since. If your store tracks gift messages or ship-to addresses, add anyone who sent an order somewhere other than their own address. 
What to send them: a gift email that picks up where last year left off. Open with “Shopping for them again?” and show a few new gifts near what they spent last time. Put your shipping cutoff right under the button. When: this week, then again about a week before your cutoff. Leave the win-back discount out. The reminder of who they shopped for last year does the work. | Email breakdown Athletic Brewing’s gift email: tell shoppers who each bundle is forGift shoppers start with a person and work back to a product. Athletic Brewing makes non-alcoholic beer, and this holiday email is built around gift bundles. The smartest thing in it is one short line of copy that tells the giver exactly who a bundle is for. Let’s break it down. See the full email on Really Good Emails → Header block
Let’s start at the top, where Athletic shows the hat, the tote and the glass right next to the can. That tells gift shoppers early that these bundles come with something to unwrap. What we love: The headline names the job of the email. “Give the gift of great taste” tells the reader this is a gifting email in the first five words. The subhead names three kinds of people. “Whether they’re an adventurer, athlete, or brand new to Athletic” gets the shopper picturing someone on their list before they scroll. There’s one yellow button against a bright blue background, so there’s no question about where to tap. The subject line carries the joke. “Because socks are a cry for help” pokes at the default gift to earn the open, so the email itself can stay clean and on brand.
What we’d do differently: The subhead promises bundles for adventurers, athletes and first-timers, and the email only shows one of them. Either show all three or cut the subhead down to the one it delivers. Add a shipping cutoff under the button. A line like “Order by December 15th for delivery by Christmas” is the most useful thing a gift email can say in December.
Body block
Now let’s dig into the body, where the best line in the email sits above the product name. What we love: “For the NA-curious or first-timers” labels the bundle by who it’s for. The shopper can match the gift to a person before they compare what’s inside. “Starter Bundle” is a plain name that backs up the label. A first-timer’s bundle called the Starter Bundle needs no explanation. The game-night photo shows the beer on a table with friends, so the shopper can picture where the gift ends up. “Shop All Gift Bundles” catches anyone the Starter Bundle didn’t fit.
What we’d do differently: Show the price. Budget is the first filter for a gift, and a bundle with no price makes the shopper click just to find out if it’s in range. Spell out the “extras.” The photo shows a glass and a sticker pack, so name them in the copy and make the bundle feel bigger. Give the adventurer and the athlete their own bundles, each with a label, a photo and a button. The header already promised them, and the label treatment is the strongest thing in this email.
Footer block
As the email winds down, Athletic uses the footer to push the relationship past this one order. What we love: “Download the Athletic App” and “Join the Athletic Club” get the two colored buttons, above Shop Brews and Shop Merch. Both are retention plays, and Athletic ranks them first. Store Finder gives a late shopper a way to buy today, in person. The B Corp logo is a trust signal for someone spending money on a gift.
What we’d do differently: Where this email worksLet’s zoom out and see where this fits in your holiday calendar. Gift guides: labeling each product by who it’s for lets shoppers match a gift to a person before they compare products. Products people are nervous to try: a “for first-timers” bundle gives someone a low-risk way to buy your product for a friend who’s never had it. Bundles that lift AOV: a curated set raises the order value and saves the giver from building a cart one item at a time. Final takeawayGift shoppers start with a person, and the faster your email connects that person to a product, the easier the sale. Athletic does it with one line of copy that tells the giver exactly who the Starter Bundle is for. The header promises three kinds of people, though, and the body only delivers one. Give each bundle its own label and the email covers far more of the names on a shopper’s list. When you sell gifts, label every product by who it’s for. 3 quick wins to steal next time✓ Label each gift by who it’s for ✓ Put a price on every bundle ✓ Deliver every persona you name in the header
| The Hiring Vault Nine retention roles that went live this weekGolf gear, fashion, fragrance, groceries, supplements, bags, outdoor gear, craft supplies and cosmetics. Everything here ships to a real address, and the list runs from specialist up to director. → Email Marketing Specialist at TaylorMade Golf, Carlsbad, CA → CRM & Retention Manager at AFRM, Culver City, CA → Senior Manager, CRM & Loyalty (NOYZ) at Beach House Group, El Segundo, CA → Senior Manager, CRM at Hungryroot, Remote → Retention Marketing Manager at Sun Coast Sciences, Remote → Senior Manager / Director, CRM & Retention at Bogg Bag, New York, NY → Director of CRM & Loyalty at Crecera Brands (Sportsman’s Guide), Bloomington, MN → Director, Lifecycle Marketing at Michaels, Dallas-Fort Worth, TX → Senior Manager, Retention & Loyalty Marketing at AS Beauty Group, New York, NY
| That’s a wrap for today! Thanks for hanging with Chase and me. If this gave you an idea for your next send, share ecomemailmarketer.com with your favorite DTC marketer. Remember: Do shit you love. 🤘 Jimmy Kim & Chase Dimond PS: Your next best customer might be reading this right now. Want in? Email Jimmy to sponsor this newsletter and more. Want to receive it less frequently? Update your cadence here | | You received this email because you subscribed to our newsletter. |
|
Reply