Gift guide emails tend to miss the mark.

Too many products, too much noise, and somehow shopping for one thing suddenly feels like a full time job.

Ashley & Co took a different approach with their Father’s Day email.

Instead of throwing a massive product grid at shoppers, they kept it tight with three curated picks, thoughtful copy, and a shopping experience that feels intentional rather than pushy.

Today, we’re breaking down what Ashley & Co got right, where they’re leaving conversions on the table, and the easy fixes that could turn more browsers into buyers.

Also inside:

✔️ We’re coming to Austin, Miami & NYC and trust us, you’ll want a seat for this 😉✔️ You can now use ChatGPT to analyze campaigns, build segments, and launch emails with Omnisend
✔️ New retention marketing roles are live… is one of them your next move?

Austin. Miami. NYC. LA. Hang with Us IRL 👋

Retention isn’t broken. Most brands are just running the same tired playbook.

That’s why we’re taking the show on the road!

We’re bringing the best retention minds in eCom together for small, high impact, in person events built for real conversations, hands on workshops, and actionable tactics you can actually apply the next day.

No dumb pitches. No sitting through useless talks wondering why you came.

We're hitting these cities:

📍 Austin
📍 Miami
📍 Los Angeles
📍 New York City

Smaller rooms. Better convos. Stronger connections.

If retention is your world, you’ll want a seat at this.

→ Grab your spot before your city fills up

*Sponsored

Ashley & Co's Father's Day gift guide: Simplicity at it’s finest

Gift guides are at their best when they feel like a favor. Because let’s face it, when holidays roll around, the stress creeps in and suddenly you’re 12 tabs and 40 product pages deep.

That’s why this Father’s Day send from Ashley & Co. works. 

It’s a gift guide built for people who are short on time but still want to give something that feels intentional. The foundation is strong. But with a few structural tweaks, this could shift from nicely curated to seriously effective. Let’s get into it.

Header Block

Starting at the top, let’s take a look at what Ashley & Co. nails from the jump.

What We Love

• The "cheat sheet" framing is a strong hook. Gift guides work when they feel like a shortcut and this nails that tone right away.

• The hero image sets the pace immediately. Product-forward, styled simply, and clearly designed for someone shopping intentionally, not browsing for entertainment.

• The intro copy leans on lived experience instead of marketing language. Partners, husbands, dads, grandfathers. Real buying context, not personas.

What We'd Do Differently

• The layout lacks visual hierarchy. Everything feels equally weighted, which makes it harder to know where to look first or what matters most.

• A light directional CTA would help orient skimmers. Even something subtle like “See the edit” would give the email a little more structure without changing the tone.

• A small reassurance line about shipping or delivery would help. Something like "Order by Friday for Father's Day delivery" reduces purchase anxiety without being aggressive.

Body Block

Here's where they walk you through the three picks. One product at a time, with just enough detail to make a decision.

What We Love

• Each product gets its own space to breathe. Instead of cramming everything into a grid, they're giving you one thing to consider at a time, which makes it easier to actually process.

• The copy is descriptive without being salesy. It focuses on scent, mood, and use, not features or benefits. That’s the right move for gifting.

• The photography is clean and consistent. Every product looks premium, but still approachable.

What We'd Do Differently

• The layout here lacks flow. It's hard to skim because everything blends together visually. Breaking up with clearer product headers would help.

• More direct CTAs. Adding a "Shop [Product Name]" button under each one would let people buy immediately instead of making them hunt for a link.

Footer Block

To wrap things up, this email winds down with a casual sign-off and standard navigation.

What We Love

• The Road Trip Playlist mention is a fun touch. It adds personality without feeling forced.

• Navigation is simple and functional. Shop, Journal, Contact, Stockists; everything you'd need is right there.

What We'd Do Differently

• There's no trust signal in the footer. Adding "Free shipping over $X" or "Easy returns" would help hesitant buyers take the next step.

• A final soft CTA could help late scrollers. Something like "Browse the full collection" gives people one more entry point without being pushy.

Where This Email Works

Let's zoom out and see where this email fits in the bigger picture.

Seasonal Campaigns: This is a solid mid-funnel play for Father's Day, but the same format would work for any gifting window where people need direction over options.

Engaged Subscribers: Great for people who already know the brand but need a nudge toward what to buy. This isn't doing heavy lifting to introduce or educate; it's just making the decision easier.

Lifestyle Brands with Deep Catalogs: Perfect for brands that have a lot of SKUs but want to spotlight specific products without overwhelming people.

Final Thoughts: Strong curation, needs better structure

This email gets the big things right. The three-product approach makes decision-making easier, the copy is helpful and descriptive, and the whole thing feels on-brand from top to bottom.

But the execution could be tighter. The layout doesn't guide your eye anywhere specific, which makes it harder to skim than it should be. And without CTAs next to each product, you're relying on people to scroll all the way down or navigate on their own; which a lot of browsers just won't do.

Add some visual hierarchy, throw in product-level CTAs, and maybe surface a trust signal or two in the footer, and this email would convert a lot harder without losing any of the calm, curated energy that makes it work in the first place.

3 Quick Wins to Steal Next Time

✓ Position gift guides as help, not sales pitches, to reduce resistance
✓ Give each product its own moment instead of overwhelming with a grid
✓ Add CTAs next to individual products so shoppers can act immediately

Omnisend Just Got A Lot More Dangerous 😈

You know that feeling when a tool actually saves you time instead of creating more work?

Yeah. This is one of those.

Omnisend just launched MCP for ChatGPT, which means you can now:
✔️ Analyze campaign performance
✔️ Build audience segments
✔️ Launch emails

…without leaving ChatGPT.

No more bouncing between tabs. No more digging through dashboards trying to answer simple questions.

Just ask:
- “What campaign drove the most revenue last month?”
- “Build me a segment of VIPs who haven’t purchased in 60 days.”
- “Help me create a winback email.”

And go.

If you’re using AI to write subject lines but not to actually run smarter marketing yet… this is your sign.

→ Check out Omnisend MCP

The Hiring Vault

• Email/SMS Marketing Manager, Los Angeles, CA: Hi-Altitude Brands

• CRM & Retention Marketing Manager, Los Angeles, CA:
  ANINE BING

• Retention Marketing Associate, North Reading, MA:
  BRUNT Workwear

• Senior Associate, Email & Lifecycle Marketing, Atlanta, GA: Sid Mashburn and Ann Mashburn

• Lifecycle Marketing Manager (Email & CRM Operations), Irvine, CA: RENPHO

• CRM Manager, Brooklyn, NY: Ana Luisa

That's a wrap for today!

Appreciate you hanging with Chase and me. We hope you found something you can put to work ASAP.

If you did, don’t keep it to yourself! Send ecomemailmarketer.com to your favorite DTC marketer and get them in on the action.

Catch you next time!

🤘 Jimmy Kim

PS - Your next best customer might be reading this right now. Want in? Email Jimmy to sponsor this newsletter and more.

Love this newsletter but want to receive it less frequently? Let us know by clicking here!