Ever bought a chocolate bar that came with instructions?

Alice Mushrooms did and honestly, it kind of slaps.

Their brainstorm email doesn't just sell a mushroom chocolate. It hands you a script for your night out: pop one, feel social, don't be weird about it. Step-by-step. Like an IKEA manual, but for mushroom chocolate.

Today we're cracking it open: what's working, what's leaving money on the table, and the one tweak that would print sales.

Also inside:
→ How to make your email campaigns run like meta ads
→ The eCom Retention Vault : Recover one cart and it pays for itself 18x over.
→ The 45+ email swipe file you definitely need
→ 6 fresh retention + lifecycle roles live on LinkedIn right now. Go get one.

Alright, grab a coffee and let's kick off our Monday. 👇

Your email campaigns are running on a 2010 operating system

Quick reality check. 

Open Meta Ads Manager and look at how a campaign is actually built. There's no ad in there. 

There's a library. Headlines, images, CTAs sitting on a shelf. The algorithm assembles them per impression… and every person who scrolls past sees a different version.

Now open your ESP. 

One layout. One headline. One hero. Shipped to everyone. 

Meta marketers stock libraries. Email marketers build campaigns. 

Allan brings the library model to email. 

You stock the shelf with headlines, heroes, copy, offers. Allan assembles, per send, per subscriber. 

12 × 6 × 4 × 3 = 864 possible emails. You wrote 25 assets.

→ Start free at getallan.com

*Sponsored

The vault 350+ retention marketers already raided

PSA from us to you: Most retention marketers don't have a creativity problem.

They have a proof problem and they're guessing what works.

We watched what actually worked across hundreds of brands and put it in a vault.

Inside The eCom Retention Vault:
→ 50 ready to send campaigns (with AI prompts so you skip the blank page)
→ 75+ real brand emails that converted & steal the structure
→ 130+ welcome flows, fully broken down
→ 10 copywriting frameworks built for revenue
→ 350+ retention nerds in the private community

$27. One time. Lifetime access.

Recover one extra cart and you've made your money back 18x.

👉 Grab the Vault →

Cheaper than lunch. Way better ROI.

*Sponsored

Alice Mushrooms' "Party Trick" email: Turning product benefits into a how-to guide

Alice Mushrooms didn't just send a "buy our product" email.

They sent a step-by-step guide on how to use their "Party Trick" chocolate to improve your night out; when to take it, what to expect at 15 minutes, what happens after an hour.

It's product education disguised as a how-to guide, which is a smart angle when you're selling something functional that people might not totally understand yet.

The education is strong and the visuals are clean, but the execution leaves conversions on the table. No CTAs within the steps, no social proof backing up the claims, and no trust signals to help nervous first-time buyers feel confident.

Let's break down what's working and where there's room to improve.

Header Block

Right at the top, Alice sets up the premise with a catchy hook and clear product focus.

What We Love

• "Work is done, let's play" is a strong opener. It immediately signals the shift from productivity to fun, which sets up the use case.

• The intro copy ties the product to a specific moment. "When work ends, party trick begins. The chocolate square that puts you straight into a bubbly, off the clock mood." It's clear about what the product does and when you'd use it.

• The hero image is styled beautifully. The product on a champagne coupe with a cork creates an immediate association with celebration and nightlife.

• The CTA is clear. "Shop party trick" tells you exactly what you're buying.

• The black background with white text creates strong contrast and makes everything easy to read.

What We'd Do Differently

• The layout feels tight. More breathing room around the headline and product image would make it easier to scan quickly.

• There's no pricing or urgency. Adding "Starting at $X" or "Limited stock" would give people more reason to act now instead of later.

Body Block

Here's where they walk you through a three-step process for using the product throughout your night.

What We Love

• The step-by-step format is genius. "Step one: take a square," "15 minutes," "1 hour and beyond." It removes guesswork about how and when to use the product.

• Each step has a clear icon. The globe, the people dancing, the celebration person. It makes the email scannable even if you're not reading every word.

• The copy ties benefits to specific moments. "Feel the trickle of excitement," "notice your mood lift," "enjoy additional squares throughout the evening." It helps you visualize the experience.

• The instructions are specific without being clinical. They're explaining effects and timing in a way that feels approachable, not intimidating.

What We'd Do Differently

• No social proof. Customer testimonials or reviews about actual experiences would make the promised benefits feel more credible.

• The dosing guidance is vague. "Start with one square and enjoy up to four as the night unfolds" gives you a range, but not much context about body weight, tolerance, or what's typical. Adding reassurance like "most people start with one" would help anxious first-timers.

Footer Block

Alice closes with a final CTA and minimal navigation.

What We Love

• The final "Shop party trick" CTA gives you one more clear path to purchase.

• Social links are easy to spot and cover the right platforms.

• The tagline "made with ✨ in los angeles" adds personality without being over the top.

• The overall tone stays consistent. Nothing here feels like a sudden shift.

What We'd Do Differently

• There's no navigation to other products. If someone isn't interested in Party Trick but wants to explore other offerings (like Brainstorm or Nightcap), they have no clear path.

• The footer could reinforce trust. Adding "Free shipping over $X" or "30-day guarantee" would help hesitant buyers take the next step.

• No mention of ingredients or certifications. For a functional product, some people want reassurance about what's actually in it before buying.

Where This Email Works

Let's zoom out and see where this fits in the bigger email strategy.

Product Education: This is perfect for functional products where people need to understand not just what it is, but how and when to use it.

New Customer Acquisition: Great for people who are curious about mushroom supplements but intimidated by the category. The step-by-step makes it approachable.

Occasion-Based Marketing: Smart for Friday afternoons or pre-weekend sends when people are thinking about going out.

Final Thoughts: Great education, needs more conversion support

This email does an excellent job of teaching people how to use the product. The step-by-step format removes confusion, the visuals are strong, and the copy makes the benefits feel real and approachable.

But it's leaving conversions on the table. There are no CTAs within the instructional section, no social proof to back up the claims, and no trust signals to help nervous first-time buyers feel confident. Adding buy buttons after the steps, including a customer testimonial or two, and surfacing a guarantee would help convert more browsers without losing the educational, helpful vibe.

3 Quick Wins to Steal Next Time

✓ Structure product emails as how-to guides when you're selling something people need to learn to use
✓ Break usage into time-based steps so people can visualize the experience
✓ Add CTAs at the end of instructional content so interested readers can buy immediately

45+ Emails You'd Pay to Have Written For You

Staring at a blank campaign brief is the most expensive thing a marketer does all week.

Omnisend just dropped a swipeable library of 45+ ecommerce emails sorted by lifecycle stage, with the exact tactics that made each one work. Welcome flows, cart abandons, browse abandons, post-purchase, re-engagement, the lot.

A few numbers from inside:

✔️ Welcome emails hit 33.79% open rate and 2% conversion
✔️ Browse abandonment lands a 42.16% open rate
✔️ Cart recovery sees 39.46% click-to-conversion
✔️ Omnisend customers earn $79 for every $1 spent on email + SMS

It's the swipe file you'd normally pay a consultant to build for you. Steal freely.

→ See the 45+ examples

The Hiring Vault

• Senior Manager, CRM & Retention Marketing, Park City, UT: Skullcandy Inc.

• Retention Marketing Manager - CRM, Somerville, MA: PUMA Group

• Email & SMS Marketing Specialist, Manhattan Beach, CA: Skechers

• Director, Lifecycle Marketing, Duluth, MN: maurices

• CRM Manager, Los Angeles Metropolitan Area: FabFitFun

• Push and SMS Marketing Manager, Boston, MA: Wayfair

That's a wrap for today!

Appreciate you hanging with Chase and me. We hope you found something you can put to work ASAP.

If you did, don’t keep it to yourself! Send ecomemailmarketer.com to your favorite DTC marketer and get them in on the action.

Catch you next time!

🤘 Jimmy Kim

PS - Your next best customer might be reading this right now. Want in? Email Jimmy to sponsor this newsletter and more.

Love this newsletter but want to receive it less frequently? Let us know by clicking here!