We've seen our fair share of product launches (we're sure you have too).
A lot of them try to tell you everything.

The ingredients, origin story, sourcing, founder's inspiration... Somewhere around scroll number five, you've forgotten what actually launched.

When UNREAL recently launched their new peanut butter drops they leaned hard on the K-I-S method.

They introduce the product, give you a few compelling reasons to care, and make buying ridiculously easy; no information overload, no overthinking.

This morning, we're breaking down why that approach works, where the email could convert even harder, and what every product launch can learn from it.

Also inside:
→ Plot twist: Your cart abandoners didn’t ghost you… you just didn’t pick up the phone.
→ Auto-reply on? Your second chance to save $500
→ Two SMS messages from CAKES that prove personality still wins
→ Hiring vault: 7 New retention marketing job ops

Alright, grab a coffee and let's kick off our Monday. 👇

Plot twist: Your cart abandoners didn’t ghost you… you just didn’t pick up the phone.

Everyone's cart recovery strategy has been wrong for ten years. Including yours.
We've been writing cart recovery flows on the same assumption for a decade. 

They hesitated. They wandered off. They need a discount to come back. 

But what if the cart sitting there isn't a buying signal at all? What if they just had a question, and your sequence couldn't answer it?

That's Outcraft. 

An AI voice agent actually calls abandoned checkouts (in minutes, not days), then coordinates the SMS, email, and WhatsApp follow-up from the same brand trained brain.

Email's been getting better at reminding for ten years.
This gets better at finishing the conversation.

See what recovered revenue sounds like → outcraft.ai

*Sponsored

Unreal's Peanut Butter Drops launch: Big personality, low friction, high excitement

Every new product launch has one job: make people care fast. That's harder than it sounds. Too many brands spend the first half of the email explaining the product instead of giving people a reason to want it.

Unreal skips all of that. They introduce Peanut Butter Drops with a big personality, a handful of meaningful reasons to care, and then lets the shopper decide if it’s worth the click. 

Let's break down what's working and where a few small tweaks could make the launch even stronger.

The Header

Let's start at the top, where Unreal wastes no time introducing what's new. The excitement lands immediately, and the product stays front and center from the very first scroll.

What We Love:

• "MIC. DROP." is a fun, confident launch headline. It creates excitement without needing a paragraph of explanation.

• The packaging gets hero treatment. There's no confusion about what's new or where your attention should go.

• The bright color palette feels unmistakably Unreal. It grabs attention while reinforcing the playful brand personality.

• The first CTA appears quickly, giving high-intent shoppers an easy path to purchase.

What We'd Do Differently:

• A launch like this deserves a little more urgency. A simple "Limited release" or "Available while supplies last" callout near the hero would give shoppers another reason to buy now instead of later.

• The hero focuses heavily on the bag. Showing a handful of Peanut Butter Drops outside the package would make the product feel more tangible before asking for the click.

The Body

Once the excitement is established, the email shifts into answering the next question shoppers have: why should I buy these instead of every other peanut butter snack?

What We Love:

• The benefit stack is short, focused, and easy to scan. Less sugar, organic peanut butter, and no artificial dyes are exactly the kinds of product truths shoppers compare.

• The copy stays playful while still communicating value. It never falls into ingredient jargon or wellness clichés.

• Giving shoppers the option to buy from Unreal.com or Whole Foods is a nice touch. The brand meets customers where they already shop instead of forcing one path.

• The multiple CTAs throughout the email keep momentum moving without feeling repetitive.

What We'd Do Differently:

• This is a missed opportunity to show where Peanut Butter Drops fit into someone's day. A simple moment like "your afternoon snack," "desk drawer," or "post-workout treat" would make the launch feel more relatable than nutritional.

• The product stays inside the bag for the entire email. Showing the Drops in someone's hand or broken open would help shoppers visualize exactly what they're buying.

The Footer

Rather than introducing something new, Unreal uses the bottom of the email to reinforce the launch and give shoppers one last chance to buy.

What We Love:

• The playful "Let's Hang Out." sign-off feels authentic to the brand instead of reading like another generic social CTA.

• The footer stays clean and uncluttered. Once the launch message has landed, nothing distracts from the product.

• Social icons are easy to find without competing with the primary goal of the email.

What We'd Do Differently:

• One final launch reminder like "Now Available" or "Freshly Dropped" would reinforce that this is still a new release and carry the excitement through the final scroll.

• The footer could carry a trust signal. A "free shipping over $X" or a satisfaction line would give a first-time buyer the last nudge they need before they commit to a candy they've never tasted.

• There's no path to the rest of the catalog. UNREAL sells cups, gems, and more, and a reader who isn't sold on peanut butter drops has nowhere to go but out. A simple "Shop all UNREAL" link recovers that traffic.

Where This Email Works

New Product Launches: This email builds excitement first, then gives shoppers just enough information to feel confident clicking through. It understands that a launch isn't the place to explain everything.

Impulse Purchases: Bright creative, fast pacing, and multiple CTAs make this easy to buy before shoppers have time to overthink the decision.

Retail + DTC Strategy: Pointing shoppers toward Unreal.com, Whole Foods, and Amazon removes friction and lets them buy wherever they're already comfortable shopping.

Final Takeaway

This email is a good reminder that launch emails don't need to answer every question. Their job is to create enough excitement to earn the next click.

Unreal keeps the focus exactly where it belongs. The product gets introduced quickly, the benefits are easy to understand, and the buying journey never feels complicated.

The biggest opportunity is helping shoppers picture the product beyond the packaging. A little more merchandising and a little more urgency would make an already strong launch even stronger.

3 Things Worth Stealing

✓ Build excitement before you explain everything

✓ Help shoppers picture where your product fits into their daily routine

✓ Make buying feel easy while excitement is still high

Auto-reply on? Your second chance to save $500

We know a lot of you actually unplugged for the holiday.

If your out-of-office reply was doing its job this weekend, there's a good chance this sale got buried under a weekend's worth of emails.

So we're giving you one more shot.

Use code MERICA to save $500 on eCom Email Certified, our complete playbook for ecommerce retention marketers. More than 175 lessons covering flows, campaigns, segmentation, deliverability, AI, copywriting, and more.

Grab your certification before the sale ends (for good) tomorrow!

→ Save $500

Read receipts:

Okay, these made us LOL. 😂 CAKES has been putting out some of our favorite SMS lately because they actually sound like they were written by a person.

They're funny, a little unhinged, and somehow still manage to sell the product without feeling like an ad. That's not easy to pull off, but they nailed it.

The Hiring Vault

• Retention Marketing Manager, New York, NY: Fleur du Mal

• Retention Marketing Manager, Charlotte, NC: Feetures

• Senior Manager, CRM & Retention Marketing, New York, NY: ANINE BING

• Email Marketing & CRM Manager, Los Angeles, CA: GENTLE MONSTER

• Retention Marketing Lead, New York, NY: Lyra Collective

• Email/SMS Lifecycle Marketing Associate, United States: Nutrafol

• Senior Manager, Retention & Lifecycle Marketing, Nampa, ID Gymreapers

That's a wrap for today!

Appreciate you hanging with Chase and me. We hope you found something you can put to work ASAP.

If you did, don’t keep it to yourself! Send ecomemailmarketer.com to your favorite DTC marketer and get them in on the action.

Catch you next time!

🤘 Jimmy Kim

PS - Your next best customer might be reading this right now. Want in? Email Jimmy to sponsor this newsletter and more.

Love this newsletter but want to receive it less frequently? Let us know by clicking here!