Mon 8/17 | Ed 394 | Graza's reorder email: Nails the personality, skips the personalization

Your favorite eCom event is almost here. 🌊 Commerce Roundtable San Diego, Sept 21 and 22 → Save 40% with code EEMVIP

The easiest sale you'll make is the reorder.

Someone already bought, already liked it, and is about to run out. The product's proven. All you have to do is show up at the right moment and make buying again easy.

Sounds simple. Plenty of brands still fumble it, usually by sending a reminder that reads like a receipt and burying the one button that matters.

Graza doesn't fumble the vibe. Their "down to the last drizzle" reorder email is fun, on brand, and one tap to buy again. It also leaves a little money on the table, and the fixes are small.

This morning we're breaking down what it nails, where it could convert harder, and what you can steal for your own post-purchase flow.

Grab a coffee and let's kick off the week. 👇

Also inside:
→ How one gin brand got half its customers coming back
→ 750 operators, one waterfront room, 40% off your seat
→ The summer perk we'd take over another 20% off.
→ Hiring vault: 7 New retention marketing job ops

The Gin Way had the list. It just wasn't bringing anyone back.

Premium Italian gin, a real community of enthusiasts, and an email program that wasn't turning either into repeat business. Retention was the gap they set out to close.

So they rebuilt on Omnisend. Cleaner templates across every send, the automations that earn their keep (welcome, abandoned cart, checkout reminders, post-purchase), and campaigns made for their community, monthly gin picks and cocktail recipes people actually open.

The payoff:

• Email revenue up 4x

• Automated flows now drive 25% of email revenue

• Subscriptions up 55%

• 54.71% of customers come back

"Revenue from email marketing increased by over 4x," says founder Alessio Piceci.

Turns out the list you already have is worth a lot more when you actually talk to it.

👉 Read the full story

*Sponsored

Reorders should be your easiest revenue. The customer already bought, already liked it, and is about to run out, so at that point you're not really selling the product anymore. You're just making it easy to grab more.

Graza's replenishment email gets that. It's fun, it's on brand, and reordering takes one tap. It also leaves a few conversions on the table, so let's break down what it nails, where it could push harder, and what you can steal.

Header Block

Most reorder emails get straight to it: you're running low, buy more.
Graza plays it a bit differently. It opens like it actually wants to know how your first bottle went, then puts the ask right behind that goodwill.
Checking in first is what earns you the right to sell second, and everything below is Graza executing on that one decision.

What We Love

• Opening on a question makes the email feel like a relationship touch, not a sales blast, so the reader stays in it long enough to reach the reorder ask.

• "Down to the last drizzle?" does the scarcity work in the subject line, and it's tied to the real product experience instead of a fake countdown.

• The hero centers on using the product, squeezing it over real food, which quietly reinforces the reason to reorder: you're actually going through it.

What We'd Do Differently

• The email asks how your first taste went but gives no way to answer. A one-tap rating or a reply prompt would turn a rhetorical question into real first-party feedback and keep the thread going.

• Name the product they bought. "How was your first taste of Drizzle?" beats the generic brand-level line and makes the email feel personalized instead of blasted.

Body Block

The middle is where the reorder actually happens, and Graza keeps it to one job: get you back to the product. A "Ready for a refill?" headline and a "Buy Again" button do exactly that, and nothing else competes for the click.

What We Love

• "Buy Again" is the right CTA for this moment. It assumes the relationship and removes the thinking, which is what a reorder button should do.

• "High quality olive oil that's meant to be squeezed, not saved" turns using the product up into a brand value. Reframing a fast-emptying bottle as the point is the most persuasive reorder argument they have.

• Alternating color blocks give the two ideas, refill now and here's why we're worth it, their own space instead of crowding them together.

What We'd Do Differently

• Two CTAs compete: "Buy Again" and "Shop Now." For a reorder email, pick one. Point everyone at "Buy Again" and let the few who want something new find it lower down, so the primary action is unmistakable.

• There's no reason to act today. A first-reorder nudge, a small returning-customer offer, or a subscribe-and-save pitch that saves them from ever running out again would convert the moment instead of leaving it to memory.

Footer Block

Graza wraps this send up with a clean footer that's on brand and easy to navigate.

What We Love

• The wordmark and tagline hold the brand identity to the last pixel, so even the sign-off still feels like Graza.

What We'd Do Differently

• The whole email is essentially one flat image. With images off, or in the previews some inboxes auto-generate, there's almost no live text, so the message can land blank. Building the copy and CTAs as real HTML text protects deliverability and accessibility.

• The footer is prime space for the trust signals a reorder email benefits from: a review count, a quick "why customers restock" line, or a subscribe-and-save reminder. Right now it's just nav.

Where This Email Works

• Post-Purchase Flows: the reorder step in any consumable's lifecycle, timed to when the first order runs low.

• Consumables and Refills: food, beauty, supplements, anything people finish and rebuy. The "meant to be squeezed, not saved" move works wherever usage is the reorder trigger.

• Brand-Led Retention: when your personality is a real asset, a check-in email keeps the relationship warm even with customers who aren't ready to buy yet.

Final Takeaway

The best reorder emails do two things: show up at the right moment, and make buying again effortless. Graza gets both right, and it does it with enough personality that the ask never feels pushy.

What's missing is the reason to act now. There's no personalization to prove they know what you bought, and no incentive to reorder today instead of next week. Those are small adds, and they're exactly where the extra revenue is.

Get someone to open a reorder email and you've already won the hard part. The last step is giving them a reason to tap Buy Again before they close the tab.

3 Quick Wins to Steal Next Time

✓ Open reorder emails with a check-in, not a pitch

✓ Name the exact product they bought

✓ Give one reason to reorder today, not someday

We built the opposite.

Commerce Roundtable San Diego takes over an open-air waterfront room on Sept 21 and 22. 750 operators, zero vendor panels, every session built around what's actually working this quarter.

The lineup is stacked: Ezra Firestone, Taylor Holiday, Omnisend's Rytis Lauris, HYROX's Christian Toetzke, and Skullcandy's Evin Catlett, with more dropping.

Rated 4.9 out of 5, four years running, and every past Roundtable has sold out. San Diego is capped at 750 and moving.

Use code EEMVIP for 40% off your ticket.

→ Grab your seat at commerceroundtable.com

This is how you make a $200 spend feel a little more fun. Instead of offering another percentage off, Andie Swim gave shoppers a free beach read, perfectly timed to the product and the season.

It's relevant, memorable, and gives customers a reason to build a bigger cart without discounting the swimsuits themselves.

• Director of Retention Marketing, Gardena, CA: CALPAK

• Retention Marketing Manager, Remote: Kindred Bravely

• Senior Manager, CRM & Retention Marketing, Park City, UT: Skullcandy

• CRM Manager, Austin, TX: Made In

• Senior Lifecycle Marketing Associate, New York, NY: Spot & Tango

• Manager, Lifecycle Marketing, New York, NY: Havenly Brands

• Email Marketing Manager, Los Angeles, CA: Zoe Lev Jewelry