Wed 9/2 | Ed 406 | Black Friday is 12 weeks out. Your list isn't ready.

👉 Get AI running your entire retention program with The AI Retention Operating System. Regularly $149. Yours today for $97.→ Get the full system

You're building the Q4 calendar this week. So is everyone else.

And with Black Friday 12 weeks out, someone who subscribes today gets a welcome flow, two months of sends, and maybe a first order before your first holiday email ever goes out. September's list is the list you sell to in November.

Below: what grows it this month, and why most of that stops working by Halloween.

Also inside:
→ The BFCM audit that used to take an afternoon. Now one prompt.
→ Three moves that are worthless by Halloween
→ $220,000 in prizes, if you're in the room
→ Roots goes private, and a toothpaste brand is outselling everyone on Amazon

Honestly, it's a good bet that you just won't leave your ESP.

We hear the same thing on audit calls. The bill has crept up, the tool does three things badly, and everyone on the team has a workaround they're quietly proud of.

Then somebody says "migration" and the room goes silent.

Because migration means 40 flows, segments nobody documented, forms embedded in six places on the site, and three years of customer data you're not willing to gamble on a weekend.

So you renew. Again.

If you're on Klaviyo and you've had that meeting more than once, Omnisend's team will do the move for you. They rebuild the automations, the segments, the forms, and carry the customer data across. You review it at the end.

You've been paying a premium to avoid a job someone else is offering to do.

👉 → See how much you can put back in your wallet

*Sponsored

Every lever that grows or warms a list needs a cohort to run all the way through it before the numbers mean anything. These three are cheap this week and close to useless by Halloween.

Black Friday is November 27. 12 weeks and some change from this morning and that number is most of the argument.

Everything that makes Q4 work has a lag built into it. The work without a lag is the expensive kind.

Q4 planning goes almost entirely into the sends. What to offer, when to drop it, how many reminders, who gets the early look.

All of it matters and none of it touches the variable underneath: how many people are on the list, and how warm they are when the first offer lands.

Count back from November 27

Every lever worth pulling this month pays late, and that's exactly why you pull it now.

• A popup change needs weeks of traffic before the numbers mean anything.

• A rebuilt welcome flow needs a full cohort to run all the way through.

• A volume ramp works because it's gradual.

Pull any of the three on November 10 and you get your answer in December, after the quarter that was supposed to pay for it.

The subscriber who joins on November 20 is the whole problem in one person. No history. A discount code as their first impression of you. Then they sit in your heaviest sending week of the year as an address that has never opened anything. That is the exact profile inbox providers use to decide where the rest of your send goes.

Anything that needs a cohort to cycle through wants to be live by the first week of October. That's four weeks from Friday.

Change the popup this week

Most brands are running a popup they wrote in February. Ten percent off, first order, a headline nobody has read since the day it went live.

The two variables that move capture rate most are both a half-hour job:

• What you ask for. An email field on its own converts better than email plus phone plus birthday, and everything else can be collected later in the flow.

• What you offer. A discount isn’t automatically the strongest thing you’ve got. Early access to the Black Friday sale is free to give away in September, it costs nothing in margin, and it self-selects for people who already intend to buy something at the end of the year.

If you sell anything with a size, a shade, or a scent, ask that instead of the birthday. That one question is worth more in November than a birth date ever will be, because it decides which of your four Black Friday emails that person should get.

Rewrite the welcome flow before the queue fills

The welcome flow is the only thing every new subscriber sees, and in most accounts it’s also the oldest thing in there. Omnisend’s 2026 benchmarks put welcome emails at $6.16 per email sent and a 35.53% open rate. That’s well clear of anything else in a normal program. The version producing those numbers is usually a three-email chain someone assembled during onboarding and never opened again.

Three edits, in order of what they’re worth:

• Move the discount out of email one. The people most likely to pay full price are the ones who just found you and are still reading, and handing them a code in the first thirty seconds trains a habit you’ll be paying for all quarter.

• Put something genuinely useful in the flow with no product grid attached. The sizing guide, the how-to-choose, whatever your support inbox answers over and over.

• Check the delays. A flow with three days between emails means someone who subscribes on Halloween is still mid-sequence when your first Black Friday send goes out, reading two different versions of your brand in the same afternoon.

  

Ramp your volume now, not in November

Inbox providers read a sudden jump in sending roughly the way a bank reads a sudden jump in spending. A brand that sends four campaigns in October and twenty in November looks different in a way that has nothing to do with the copy.

The fix is unglamorous and it has to start now:

• Add a send a week through September and October, so November’s peak is the top of a slope.

• Point the extras at your engaged segment, which keeps the open rate climbing while the volume does.

• Quietly stop mailing anyone who hasn’t opened since spring. That’s painless in September and a genuine risk in week three of November.

Start all three before Halloween

Change the popup this week, rewrite the welcome flow before the end of the month, and add a send a week from here on.

None of those are Q4 projects. All three need a cohort to cycle through them before the numbers say anything, which is why they stop being useful sometime in early November, roughly when most brands get around to them.

We’re handing out $220,000+ in prizes at Commerce Roundtable San Diego on September 21 and 22, and one of them is a $100K Shared Sweeps for two lucky brand attendees.

• 🌴 Vacation getaways

• 📱 iPads and MacBooks

• 🛍 Products from the hottest DTC brands

• 🎁 A constant stream of surprise prizes you have to be there to see

The catch? Just make sure you’re in the room. 750 founders and operators, two days on the water, and maybe your next vacation on the way out.

🎟 Use code EEMVIP for 40% off.

→ Grab your seat

Marquee Brands is taking Roots private

Marquee Brands, which owns Roberto Cavalli, is buying the Canadian outdoor brand at CA$4.10 a share, about $2.98 US and a 36% premium. Roots did CA$42.6 million last quarter, up 6.5%, on a net loss over $10 million that got 27% worse. Its new operating partner takes over design, manufacturing, and the retail and ecommerce operations in both countries.

Boka went from DTC toothpaste to the top seller on Amazon

Boka is ten years old, started direct, and is now the number one toothpaste on Amazon by sales. Retail grew 481% last year, and it sits in Target and Walmart at three to four times the price of whatever’s beside it. The play is selling oral care like skincare: hydroxyapatite instead of fluoride, niacinamide on the ingredient list, and flavors called Coco Ginger and Lemon Lavender with the top and bottom notes printed on the box.

Fragrance is carrying beauty, and mass is carrying fragrance

Circana has prestige beauty up 7% to $17.1 billion in the first half, with fragrance doing most of the work. Prestige fragrance grew 6% on a 5% price rise with units flat, which is a pricing story rather than a demand one. Mass fragrance grew 15% with units up 7%, the fastest-growing mass category of the half.